Leadership
By Jason Kumpf, Strategy Advisor · November 10, 2026 · 5 min read

Field experiments and a Stanford survey of CEOs point to the same conclusion: structured advice from capable peers helps leaders and their companies grow.
Senior executives spend their days giving guidance. The best of them also make a habit of receiving it. Research from economists and business school faculty now gives that habit a measurable payoff.
Three studies stand out. Together they show that regular peer meetings lift company performance, that advice from fellow operators shapes how firms grow and that nearly every CEO welcomes outside counsel.
Economists Jing Cai and Adam Szeidl ran one of the largest experiments on business peer groups. As described in their 2016 NBER working paper, they organized the owner-managers of roughly 2,800 young firms in China into small groups that met monthly for a year, alongside a comparison group that did not meet.
The results were clear. The meetings increased firm revenue by 8.1 percent, and profit, the number of business partners and management quality also rose. The gains persisted a year after the meetings ended.
Two details matter for executives. The benefits came through practical channels, including shared information and new partnerships between members. And firms randomly placed with stronger peers grew faster, a reminder that the quality of the room shapes the value of the conversation.
A second experiment looked at founders of high-growth technology companies. Aaron Chatterji, Solène Delecourt, Sharique Hasan and Rembrand Koning, publishing in the Strategic Management Journal in 2019, studied 100 startups in India whose founders received in-person advice from fellow entrepreneurs.
Founders advised by peers who ran their companies with formal management practices, including regular meetings, consistent goal setting and frequent employee feedback, grew about 28 percent larger two years later. They were also about 10 percentage points more likely to still be operating.
The lesson is encouraging. Good management practice spreads through conversation. When a leader hears how a respected peer runs a weekly operating review or sets quarterly goals, the idea often travels straight into their own company.
The research points to three mechanisms that reinforce one another. Each one is available to any leader who joins a well-run group.
The startup experiment adds a useful nuance. Founders without formal management training, such as an MBA or an accelerator program, responded most strongly to peer advice. Peer counsel appears to be an efficient way to fill knowledge gaps quickly, which makes it especially valuable when a leader steps into a new role, a new industry or a larger company.
Peer learning also scales with experience. Senior executives bring decades of pattern recognition to the table, so a single conversation can compress years of trial and error into an afternoon.
The appetite for this kind of exchange is broad. The 2013 Executive Coaching Survey from Stanford Graduate School of Business and The Miles Group, drawing on more than 200 CEOs, board directors and senior executives, found that nearly all CEOs enjoy receiving coaching and leadership advice. Every CEO surveyed said they were open to making changes based on feedback.
The survey also revealed room to grow: nearly two-thirds of CEOs were not yet receiving outside leadership advice. That gap is an opportunity. "Even the best-of-the-best CEOs have their blind spots," said Stephen Miles of The Miles Group.
The skills CEOs most wanted to strengthen are the ones peers discuss best: sharing leadership and delegation, conflict management, team building and mentoring. Directors, for their part, most wanted their CEOs to focus on developing internal talent.
Across the research, a few design principles recur. They apply whether the group is a formal council, a personal board of advisors or a small circle of trusted counterparts.
Many executives complement a peer group with a personal board: three to five people with distinct strengths, such as a seasoned operator, a functional expert from outside your field and a leader one stage ahead in their career. A short quarterly conversation with each can sharpen major decisions and broaden your network.
The best personal boards are built deliberately. Start by listing the three decisions most likely to shape your next two years, then identify who has already made similar decisions well. Invite them with a clear, modest request, such as a 30-minute call each quarter, and come prepared with a specific question every time. Advisors tend to stay engaged when they can see their input put to work.
Mentorship works in both directions here. Senior leaders who mentor rising executives often find the exchange sharpens their own thinking, and directors in the Stanford survey ranked mentoring and developing internal talent among the skills they most valued in a CEO.
The value of a council rises with the preparation members bring. Groups that work well tend to share a few simple routines.
They open with brief updates so everyone knows what each member is working on. They give one or two members a longer slot to present a live decision, such as a reorganization, a market entry or a key hire, and invite the group to ask questions before offering advice. They close with commitments, and they revisit those commitments at the next meeting.
That rhythm mirrors the formal management practices that helped startups grow in the Chatterji study: regular meetings, clear goals and frequent feedback. A peer group run this way becomes a model of the management habits members want to strengthen in their own companies.
The evidence makes a positive case. Time spent in structured conversation with capable peers tends to return better decisions, new relationships and stronger management habits.
Leadership can feel solitary at the top. The research suggests it does not have to be, and that good counsel from peers shows up in results.